Jack Calloway sat in a dimly lit classroom at The Farm, the CIA’s legendary training ground. The air smelled faintly of coffee and gun oil, the usual perfume of the place. Instructors took turns briefing the recruits on covert operations, their voices even and deliberate, the kind of tone used by men who had seen too much and felt too little.
Today’s lesson: Title 50 and Moral Flexibility.
At the front of the room, an instructor—a former case officer with eyes like steel—tapped the whiteboard. “There’s an old saying that when diplomacy fails, and war is too messy, the good folks in Washington simply pretend the rules don’t exist. Now, this might come as a surprise to those still believing in bedtime stories about justice and international law, but the truth—like an uninvited tax collector—has a way of showing up when you least expect it.”
Jack listened, his focus unwavering, but next to him sat something far more distracting than the lecture—a woman. A beautiful woman, dark-haired, poised, and far too calm for someone in a place like this. Mossad? Shin Bet? He wasn’t sure, but the way she absorbed every word, without so much as a twitch, told him she was either exceptionally trained or exceptionally dangerous—possibly both.
“Title 50,” the instructor continued, “is the legal sleight of hand that allows the United States to do all manner of things while pretending it doesn’t. Officially, assassination is a no-no—why, Executive Order 12333 says so in plain English! But don’t let that fool you. The trick, dear students, is that what the president wants is often far more important than what the law says. And if a law doesn’t fit the occasion, well, there’s always a clever lawyer around who can stretch it until it does.”
The instructor walked to the other side of the board. “Now, let’s talk about the Third Option in U.S. foreign policy:”
- Diplomacy (the first option)
- Conventional war (the second option)
- Covert action, including assassinations (the third option)
He let the words settle before turning back. “When diplomacy fails and war is impractical, the U.S. turns to covert operations under Title 50. These actions are deniable, they are lethal, and they are absolutely necessary.”
Jack caught a slight smirk from the woman beside him. She knew all of this already.
“Title 50 vs. Title 10,” the instructor continued. “Title 10 governs military operations—open, legal warfare. Title 50 is what lets us play dirty in places we’re not supposed to be.”
- Title 50 allows the CIA to conduct deniable operations, including assassinations, in countries where the U.S. is not officially at war.
- Title 10 applies to the military (DoD), limiting it to declared war zones unless forces are sheep-dipped into the CIA for covert missions, like SEAL Team 6 in the Bin Laden raid.
“In short,” the instructor said, “Title 50 gives us the ability to act without getting caught. That means operators like you will never wear a uniform. Your weapons won’t have serial numbers. Your existence will be a whisper in the dark.”
Jack leaned forward slightly. He understood the stakes. He had spent years in the shadows as a soldier, but this was different. This was the deep end.
Moral Flexibility
“Now, let’s talk about what we’re really here for—moral flexibility.” The instructor’s tone changed. More serious now. “The CIA doesn’t need perfect soldiers. It needs men and women who can live in gray areas.”
Jack had heard it before. But here, in this room, it had a different weight.
“Moral flexibility isn’t just being able to lie. It’s understanding that some lies are necessary. That sometimes, you have to look a man in the eye, shake his hand, and tell him everything is fine—only for him to disappear an hour later. It’s about sitting across from a terrorist, a warlord, a child-trafficker, playing along, earning trust, getting them into a situation where they can be neutralized.”
Jack’s thoughts drifted for a moment. Could he do that? Could he sit across from a monster and smile, knowing that moments later, he’d end them?
“And then,” the instructor continued, “you go home. You kiss your daughter on the forehead. You eat a pork chop. You sleep soundly. Because it had to be done.”
The woman beside Jack didn’t react. Cold as steel.
Legal Cover for Assassinations
- Executive Order 12333 bans assassinations.
- Presidential Findings under Title 50 override this, making targeted killings legally permissible.
- Instead of saying “assassination,” the official language is “targeted killing” or “executive action” for political cover.
The instructor smirked. “It’s all about the paperwork.”
Examples of Title 50 Operations
- Bin Laden Raid (2011): SEAL Team 6 was temporarily assigned to the CIA to legally operate in Pakistan.
- Imad Mughniyeh Assassination (2008): A CIA-Mossad joint operation took out Hezbollah’s chief in Damascus.
- Drone Strikes: The CIA uses Title 50 to conduct drone strikes in countries where the U.S. is not at war.
Jack took notes. He’d need them.
Years later, in the field, he would know exactly why they had tested him the way they did. When you’re standing over a man who was seconds away from killing innocents, hesitation meant death.
The woman beside him finally spoke, her voice smooth, unshaken. “So basically,” she said, “it’s about knowing when to break the rules.”
The instructor chuckled. “It’s about knowing which rules were meant to be broken.”
Jack exhaled. He was ready.
Authors Comment: This is not Sci-fi, for better or worse this is how the world works for every President of the United States since 1947. Since its passage, Title 50 has been amended and expanded to govern national defense, intelligence activities, covert operations, and emergency powers. It is the legal foundation for the CIA’s covert actions, including assassinations, drone strikes, and other deniable missions.
While determining the exact number of individuals killed under operations authorized by Title 50 of the U.S. Code is challenging due to the covert nature of these missions and the lack of comprehensive public records. However, historical data from specific programs and operations provide some insight:
-
Phoenix Program (Vietnam War): Between 1968 and 1972, this CIA-led initiative aimed to dismantle the Viet Cong infrastructure. Reports indicate that approximately 26,369 individuals were killed during this period. Wikipedia
-
Operation Condor (South America): Active from 1975 to 1983, this campaign involved coordinated efforts by right-wing South American governments, with alleged U.S. support, to suppress left-wing opposition. Estimates suggest that between 60,000 to 80,000 people were killed as a result.
-
Drone Strikes (2009–2016): During President Obama’s administration, 563 drone strikes targeted regions in Pakistan, Somalia, and Yemen. These strikes resulted in the deaths of an estimated 384 to 807 civilians.
These figures, while significant, represent only a portion of the casualties associated with covert operations under Title 50. The secretive nature of such missions means that the full extent of fatalities remains undisclosed and potentially higher than reported.
BTW, I am Pro-American and I realize that sometimes you have to take out the garbage. We fall back into Moral Flexibility. May God have mercy on our souls.
0
