Learn you must, from mistakes not your own. Greed and fear, powerful they are. But master them you must, or mastered by them you will be.
You are young to the market, dazzled by flashing screens and humming algorithms. Surely, you think, there must be a better, more modern way. Those old folks didn’t know what they were doing. But like Skywalker talking to Yoda, you are wrong.
Every one of the men we’re about to discuss once thought the same way. Each came with some new trick, some fresh scheme, some clever algorithm to beat the market. And each of them lost money learning the same painful lesson: the market is not ruled by logic, by facts, or by what “should” happen. The market is driven by people—by fear, greed, and the ever-present FOMO.
That is why the greatest truths of the market were not written in code, but forged by the operators who mastered its brutal psychology. From the Silver Fox of Wall Street to the Oracle of Omaha, these ten rules form an unwritten code of survival and success.
1. “The public is always and everywhere wrong.” — James R. Keene
Keene, the “Silver Fox,” studied the herd as a predator studies prey. The crowd buys at the top in euphoria and sells at the bottom in despair. To him, the herd was not independent thinkers—it was a force of nature, predictable in its extremes.
👉 Lesson: Market tops and bottoms are written in human emotion, not balance sheets. As Buffett would later echo, “Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful.”
⚠️ Mistake: Keene himself was wiped out more than once. In 1884, overleveraged in railroad stocks, he declared bankruptcy. His own downfall proved his rule—he followed the herd into overconfidence.
2. “Judge the market by its own action, not by the news.” — Richard Wyckoff
Wyckoff taught that headlines are gossip, but the tape is truth. News is already priced in; the market’s reaction to news reveals the real condition.
👉 Lesson: Price and volume never lie. News only tells stories.
⚠️ Mistake: Wyckoff admitted that in his early days he was swayed by headlines, chasing stories and tips. It took years of painful losses before he learned that the ticker tape was the only honest witness.
👉 Example: A stock that falls on good news is being sold by insiders. A stock that rises on bad news is under accumulation. Price and volume never lie.
3. “Control the supply and you control the price.” — Jay Gould
Gould played on another level. By cornering supply, he could choke the market and dictate terms. His attempt to corner gold in 1869 nearly wrecked the economy.
👉 Lesson: Structural forces—like scarcity and float—can outweigh psychology. Modern echoes: OPEC in oil, or a short squeeze like GameStop.
⚠️ Mistake: Gould’s 1869 attempt to corner gold led to “Black Friday,” a financial panic that ruined countless speculators and stained his name. He escaped with profits, but his schemes left wreckage behind.
4. “Never meet a margin call.” — Jesse Livermore
Livermore insisted: when the market proves you wrong, close the position. Meeting a margin call is “throwing good money after bad.” It’s hope, not discipline.
👉 Lesson: Capital and clarity of mind are a trader’s lifelines. Protect both at all costs. Hope belongs in churches, not in markets.
⚠️ Mistake: Livermore’s fortunes rose and fell like the tide. He made and lost millions, often because he ignored his own rules. In the end, his failure to tame his own psychology cost him everything.
5. “Always hunt for the reason why things are so.” — Bernard Baruch
Baruch went deeper than surface explanations. He studied entire industries and causal chains before placing a bet. His fortune in sulfur came from understanding geology, technology, and demand curves.
👉 Lesson: First-level thinking asks what. Second-level thinking asks why. Baruch’s words still stand: “Every man has a right to his own opinion, but no man has a right to be wrong in his facts.”
⚠️ Mistake: Early in his career, Baruch lost money chasing tips and rumors. He realized too late that buying without understanding was gambling, not investing—so he taught himself to dig until he struck bedrock.
6. “Never be a bear on the United States.” — Cornelius Vanderbilt
The Commodore saw panics not as threats but as opportunities. While others sold in fear, he bought assets and railroads for pennies, betting on America’s inevitable rise.
👉 Lesson: Short-term storms can’t derail long-term growth. Crises are buying opportunities if you believe in the system’s future.
⚠️ Mistake: Vanderbilt’s Erie Railroad battle against Gould and Fisk was a disaster. He lost millions when his rivals illegally printed shares to dilute his stake. His optimism was right, but his trust in fairness was misplaced.
7. “The market is made by the minds of men.” — Charles Dow
Dow’s deepest insight: markets are not machines but reflections of human psychology. Trends are not numbers—they are dramas of hope, fear, and greed, played out in three acts: accumulation, public participation, and distribution.
👉 Lesson: To master markets, study human nature first—and yourself most of all.
⚠️ Mistake: Dow himself was no great trader. He watched operators succeed while he analyzed. His humility—admitting that the market was driven by psychology he couldn’t control—was his strength.
8. “Price is what you pay, value is what you get.” — Warren Buffett
Buffett separated appearance from reality. Price is a quote, value is the business beneath it. Long-term wealth comes from buying value, not chasing price action.
👉 Lesson: Focus less on daily fluctuations and more on the durability of earnings and competitive advantage. Or as he put it: “It’s far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price.”
⚠️ Mistake: Even Buffett has stumbled. His investment in airlines, for example, ended in losses. He later admitted: “I was wrong about that business.” His errors remind us that discipline, not perfection, drives success.
9. “Invert, always invert.” — Charlie Munger
Munger’s method was to flip problems upside down. Instead of asking how to win, he asked how to avoid losing. Avoid stupidity and you’ll stumble into success.
👉 Lesson: Don’t overcomplicate. Steer clear of leverage, fads, and arrogance. In Munger’s words: “It is remarkable how much long-term advantage people like us have gotten by trying to be consistently not stupid, instead of trying to be very intelligent.”
⚠️ Mistake: Munger learned this the hard way when early ventures failed. He once lost much of his net worth in real estate. That pain forged his philosophy: survival is more about avoiding ruin than chasing brilliance.
10. “Know what you own, and know why you own it.” — Peter Lynch
Lynch demanded clarity. If you couldn’t explain a company in plain English—or with a crayon—you had no business owning it.
👉 Lesson: Knowledge builds conviction. Conviction prevents panic. As Lynch warned, “Never invest in an idea you can’t illustrate with a crayon.”
⚠️ Mistake: Lynch confessed that even he sometimes bought “story stocks” that sounded exciting but had no real fundamentals. His missteps taught him the simple rule he passed on: clarity is conviction.
Conclusion
From Keene’s cynicism to Lynch’s crayons, the wisdom spans centuries but hums with one voice: the market is not about stocks, it’s about people.
- Keene: don’t trust the crowd.
- Wyckoff: trust the tape.
- Gould: control supply.
- Livermore: cut losses.
- Baruch: dig deeper.
- Vanderbilt: bet on America.
- Dow: study psychology.
- Buffett: value over price.
- Munger: avoid stupidity.
- Lynch: know what you own.
The screens may be faster, but the brain behind them is still the same. History doesn’t repeat, but it rhymes—over and over—because human nature doesn’t change.
So let us learn from these ten Yodas, and just as importantly, learn from their mistakes.
As Jesse Livermore once said, “The game does not change, and neither does human nature.”
© 2025 insearchofyourpassions.com - Some Rights Reserve - This website and its content are the property of YNOT. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to share and adapt the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as you give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.
